Reflections on the credit crunch

There is a lot of ‘I knew it would end in tears’ chat around the credit crunch at present, but less in-depth thinking about what it means and how to respond. Here are some points from conversations I have had in recent days:

  1. No-one is making an apology, but at the same time we may all be complicit, as we benefited as consumers from more extended and less expensive credit. Talking with Richard Lambert, CBI (who says “good luck to Consumer Focus in your early days!”), I floated the idea of a Truth and Reconciliation Commission on the credit crunch. We need to understand and not just condemn, or alternatively, just move on.
  2. The credit crunch was foreshadowed in the collapse of Enron, which was before a model of corporate success, but based on creative /illegal off-balance sheet accounting and disguised through charismatic leadership that was hard to question. But Enron had a whistleblower, which the credit crunch has not had. There are dissident economists who have been warning of risks for years, but they do not enjoy the protection and rights that whistleblowers now have. Perhaps we need, as a culture, to listen more to voices of dissent.
  3. One of the weaknesses of regulation has been that it has assumed that financial transactions between consenting professionals does not need the scrutiny and attention that financial deals with consumers attract. Those who work in financial markets are assumed to be alert to the risks. But what was missing, as one friend from Reuters argues, is God’s eye – in the sense that it was nobody’s role to have a look at the overall system. Regulators are not God, that much we know, but they ought to have an eye on the system overall and the incentives that led the professionals to stray.
  4. The fallout for you and I and the public at large could be awful, in the sense that the economy has been propped up high levels of employment, but with many having no savings to speak of and no real safety net, for example in public housing, is we see genuine economic distress. Annuity rates are falling for peole retiring now. Banks are busy withdrawing access to borrowing and, talking to John Fingleton of the OFT, we could see that mortgage costs may rocket in the same way that energy prices have. All of this adds up to millions of cases of what is essentially a personal credit crunch.
  5. If banks are too big to fail, and have the implicit guarantee of state protection, then we should argue that they have a reverse obligation to society, to provide payment and credit services on an equitable basis of access to all.

Welcome your views on this. I am away this week with family.


2 thoughts on “Reflections on the credit crunch

  1. Hi Ed,

    I agree with you here. This is not a time for ‘I told you so’, but time to work with the industry to develop a mutually acceptable way forward, building on CSR and other initiatives and blending these into an overarching social obligation. Credit is now so essential to households and business that we must guarantee access, and include consumer agencies more closely in new governance arrangements for this market.

    It is a great pity that you are not able to attend the Responsible Credit conference taking place on 13th and 14th November as we now have 200 delegates from 26 countries coming together to debate these issues along these very lines. The sponsorship from Citi and GE indicates at least some sections of the industry are also open to the discussion, so there is some room for optimism here. (Btw, we could still make some room for you to speak at the conference dinner on Thursday evening if you are available).

    Although I know that you weren’t able to make the event during the day yourself, it would be good to see someone from Consumer Futures at the event, and to get your views on the draft conference declaration which will be debated, which is available from this link

    I do hope that we can start to involve Consumer Futures in the growing coalition for Responsible Credit as we move forwards.

    Best wishes


  2. Dear Ed

    Trusting that you remember my unusual name, I congratulate you on your popular blog that I linked to from NEF’s triple crunch site.

    May I suggest that the crunch is a man-made design just as the National Debt, the National Debt Management Office and the Financial Services Authority which was set up by New Labour to restore public confidence but achieved its opposite?

    Maybe you’d like to click on our online petition on and consider your comment on targeting the Treasury Select Committee to look into the money supply?

    In my current analysis, nobody takes responsibility for an overview. Do you have a constructive suggestion?

    With ‘globally warm’ regards,

    Organiser, Forum for Stable Currencies

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s